Collected Essays on Finance and Economics ›› 2026, Vol. 42 ›› Issue (11): 89-100.

Previous Articles     Next Articles

Competition among Credit Rating Agencies and Inquiry in the Review of Corporate Bond Issuance and Listing

TONG Yan1, JI Mingyu1, LI Xin2,3, XIAO Shufang1   

  1. 1. School of Management, Beijing Institute of Technology, Beijing 100081, China;
    2. School of Accounting, Southwestern University of Finance and Economics, Chengdu 611130, China;
    3. Big Data Laboratory on Financial Security and Behavior, SWUFE (Laboratory of Philosophy and Social Sciences, Ministry of Education), Chengdu 611130, China
  • Received:2024-12-28 Online:2026-11-10 Published:2026-11-10

信用评级机构竞争与公司债券发行上市审核问询

佟岩1, 纪明宇1, 李鑫2,3, 肖淑芳1   

  1. 1.北京理工大学管理学院,北京 100081;
    2.西南财经大学会计学院,四川 成都 611130;
    3.教育部哲学社会科学实验室——西南财经大学金融安全与行为大数据实验室,四川 成都 611130
  • 通讯作者: 李鑫(1995—),男,山西阳泉人,西南财经大学会计学院、教育部哲学社会科学实验室——西南财经大学金融安全与行为大数据实验室副教授
  • 作者简介:佟岩(1977—),女,吉林长春人,北京理工大学管理学院教授;纪明宇(2002—),男,河北唐山人,北京理工大学管理学院博士生;肖淑芳(1957—),女,北京市人,北京理工大学管理学院教授
  • 基金资助:
    国家自然科学基金项目(72072012;72472023)

Abstract: Maintaining the stability of the bond market is an important responsibility of bond market regulation. However, the exposure of credit risks in some bonds has brought the credit rating industry into wide public attention. Existing literature suggests that competition among rating agencies leads to a decline in rating quality. Therefore, this paper intends to analyze the responses of market regulators from the perspective of competition among rating agencies. Based on the feedback letters on the issuance and listing of corporate bonds publicly issued on the Shanghai and Shenzhen Stock Exchanges from May 2015 to December 2022, the study finds that intensified competition among rating agencies prompts the exchanges to conduct more inquiries into the corporate bond issuance and listing review. The mechanism test reveals that intensified competition among rating agencies leads to an increase in exchanges' review inquiries through increasing the degree of “rating shopping” and “rating catering”. Meanwhile, the impact of rating-agency competition on exchanges' review inquiries is more pronounced for issuers with high operational risk or with low audit quality, and those in regions with higher marketization, particularly after the implementation of the new Securities Law. This paper has practical significance for exploring and improving the bond market regulation mechanism.

Key words: Competition in the Credit Rating Market, Credit Rating Quality, Corporate Bond Issuance and Listing Review

摘要: 维护债券市场稳定是债券市场监管的重要目标。部分债券信用风险的暴露使得信用评级行业受到广泛关注。现有文献认为评级机构竞争会导致评级质量下降,因此本文从信用评级机构竞争的角度分析其引发的市场监管部门反应。基于2015年5月—2022年12月沪深交易所对公司债券发行上市审核形成的反馈意见函,研究发现,评级机构竞争加剧会加大交易所对公司债券发行上市进行审核问询的力度。机制检验发现,评级机构竞争加剧会提高“评级选购”和“评级迎合”程度,进而使交易所加大审核问询力度。同时,经营风险较高、审计质量较低、所在地区市场化程度较高的发行人以及新《证券法》实施后,评级机构竞争对交易所审核问询力度的影响更为明显。文章对于探索完善债券市场监管机制具有一定的实践意义。

关键词: 评级市场竞争, 信用评级质量, 债券发行上市审核

CLC Number: