价值总是被共同创造吗？——价值共同破坏研究综述与展望

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 随着学术界对价值共创理论不断深入研究,价值共创的对立面——价值共同破坏理论吸引了众多学者的眼球,国际学术界掀起了研究价值共同破坏理论的热潮。然而在国内,鲜有学者专门研究价值共同破坏。本文主要对国外价值共同破坏的文献进行梳理,阐述并介绍国外学者对价值共同破坏及其相关概念的理解,厘清价值共同破坏相关概念间的区别与联系,综述国外价值共同破坏理论的研究现状,并提出未来研究展望。期望能够引起国内学者对价值共同破坏研究的重视,并为后续研究提供清晰的脉络以及研究的思路。

关键词: 价值, 价值共创, 价值共同破坏, 价值减少, 价值破坏

Abstract: With the continuous deepening research on the theory of value co-creation in the academia, the opposite aspect of value co-creation ——the theory of value co-destruction has attracted the attention of many scholars. The craze research on the theory of value co-destruction has been set off in the international academia. However, no research paper of value co-destruction has been found in the domestic academia. This paper mainly reviews the research literature about “value co-destruction” in the foreign academia, elaborates and introduces the concept of value co-destruction and its related concepts, and clarifies the differences and relations between these concepts and the concept of value co-destruction, and puts forward the prospect of future research. It is hoped that this article can draw domestic scholars' attention to the study of value co-destruction, and provide a clear clue and research ideas for the follow-up researchers in the domestic academia.

Key words: Value, Value Co-creation, Value Co-destruction, Value Diminution, Value Destruction

中图分类号:

F274

李朝辉, 卜庆娟, 许倩倩, 曹冰. 价值总是被共同创造吗？——价值共同破坏研究综述与展望[J]. 财经论丛, 2019, 35(5): 94-103.

LI Zhaohui, BU Qingjuan, XU Qianqian, CAO Bing. Is Value always Co-Created?——Research on Value Co-destruction Literature Review and Future Prospect[J]. , 2019, 35(5): 94-103.

参考文献

[1] Echeverri P., Skålén P. Co-creation and Co-destruction: A Practice-Theory Based Study of Interactive Value Formation[J]. Marketing Theory, 2011, 11(3), pp.351-373.
[2] Plé L., Cáceres R. C. Not always Co-creation: Introducing Interactional Co-destruction of Value in Service-Dominant Logic[J]. Journal of Services Marketing, 2010, 24(6), pp.430-437.
[3] Prahalad C. K., Ramaswamy V. Co-creation Experiences: The Next Practice in Value Creation[J]. Journal of Interactive Marketing, 2004, 18(3), pp.5-14.
[4] Jaworski B., Kohli A. Co-creating the Voice of the Customer[A]. Lusch R. F., Vargo S. L(Eds.). The Service-dominant Logic of Marketing: Dialog, Debate and Directions[M]. Armonk, NY: M. E. Sharpe, 2006, pp.109-117.
[5] Woodruff R. B., Flint D. J. Marketing's Service Dominant Logic and Customer Value[A]. Lusch R. F., Vargo S. L(Eds.). The Service-dominant Logic of Marketing: Dialog, Debate and Directions[M]. Armonk, NY: M. E. Sharpe, 2006, pp.183-195.
[6] Grönroos C. Value Co-creation in Service Logic: A Critical Analysis Marketing Theory[J]. 2011,11(3), pp.279-301.
[7] Lambert D., Enz M. Managing and Measuring Value Co-creation in Business-to-Business Relationships[J]. Journal of Marketing Management, 2012, 28(13/14), pp.1588-1625.
[8] Gummerus J. Value Creation Processes and Value Outcomes in Marketing Theory: Strangers or Siblings?[J]. Marketing Theory, 2013,13(1), pp.19-46.
[9] Lintula J., Tuunanen T., and Salo M. The Dynamics between Value Co-creation and Value Co-destruction in Business Service Networks[C]. Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences, 2017.
[10] 李朝辉. 基于顾客参与视角的虚拟品牌社区价值共创机理研究[D]. 北京:北京邮电大学博士学位论文, 2013.
[11] 简兆权, 令狐克睿, 李雷. 价值共创研究的演进与展望——从“顾客体验”到“服务生态系统”视角[J]. 外国经济与管理, 2016, 38(9):3-20.
[12] 卜庆娟, 金永生, 李朝辉. 互动一定创造价值吗？——顾客价值共创互动行为对顾客价值的影响[J]. 外国经济与管理, 2016, 38(9):21-37.
[13] 莫水凤. 顾客参与价值共创之“黑暗面”的反思[J]. 江苏商论,2017,(11):35-39.
[14] 王璐. 价值共创的利与弊[J]. 企业管理,2017,(4):110-113.
[15] Smith A. M. The Value Co-destruction Process:A Customer Resource Perspective[J]. European Journal of Marketing, 2013, 47(11-12), pp.1889-1909.
[16] Leclercq T., Hammedi W., Poncin I. Ten Years of Value Cocreation: An Integrative Review[J]. Recherche Et Applications En Marketing, 2016,31(3), pp.26-60.
[17] Prior D. D., Marcos-Cuevas J. Value Co-destruction in Interfirm Relationships: The Impact of Actor Engagement Styles[J]. Marketing Theory, 2016, 16(4), pp.533-552.
[18] Järvi H., Kähkönen A. K., Torvinen H. When Value Co-creation Fails: Reasons that Lead to Value Co-destruction[J]. Scandinavian Journal of Management, 2018,34 (1), pp.63-77.
[19] Vartiainen T., and Tuunanen T. Value Co-creation and Co-destruction in An IS Artifact: Contradictions of Geocaching[C]. The 49th Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences (HICSS), 2016, 1266-1275.
[20] Daunt K. L., Harris L. C. Consumer Showrooming: Value Co-destruction[J]. Journal of Retailing & Consumer Services, 2017, 38, pp.166-176.
[21] Makkonen H., Olkkonen R. Interactive Value Formation in Interorganizational Relationships: Dynamic Interchange between Value Co-creation, No-creation, and Co-destruction[J]. Marketing Theory, 2017,17(1), pp.1-19.
[22] Vafeas M., Hughes T., Hilton T. Antecedents to Value Diminution: A Dyadic Perspective[J]. Marketing Theory, 2016, 16(4), pp.469-491.
[23] Worthington S. and Durkin M. Co-destruction of Value in Context: Cases from Retail Banking[J]. The Marketing Review, 2012, 12(3), pp.291-307.
[24] Kashif M., and Zarkada A. Value Co-destruction between Customers and Frontline Employees: A Social System Perspective[J]. International Journal of Bank Marketing, 2015, 33(6), pp.672-691.
[25] Palumbo R. Value Co-creation and Value Co-destruction in the Patient-Provider Relationship-The Contribution of the“Health Literacy” Perspective[C]. Conference of the EuroMed Academy of Business-Innovation, Entrepreneurship & Sustainable Value Chain in A Dynamic Environment, 2015.
[26] Robertson N., Polonsky M. and McQuilken L. Are My Symptoms Serious Dr Google? A Resource-based Typology of Value Co-destruction in Online Self-diagnosis[J]. Australasian Marketing Journal, 2014, 22(3), pp. 246-256.
[27] Camilleri J., Neuhofer B. Value Co-creation and Co-destruction in the Airbnb Sharing Economy[J]. International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management, 2017, 29(9), pp.2322-2340.
[28] Mills G. R. W., Razmdoost K. Managing Value Co-creation/destruction: A Longitudinal Education Capital Programme/Project Case Study[J]. Construction Management & Economics, 2016, 34, pp.1-16.
[29] Stieler M., Weismann F., Germelmann C.C. Co-destruction of Value by Spectators: The Case of Silent Protests[J]. European Sport Management Quarterly, 2014, 14(1), pp.72-86.
[30] Becker S. V., Aromaa E., Eriksson P. Client-Consultant Interaction: The Dynamics of and Conflicts in Value Co-creation and Co-destruction[J]. International Journal of Services Technology & management, 2015,21 (1/2/3), pp.40.
[31] Uppström E., Lönn C. M. Explaining Value Co-creation and Co-destruction in E-Government Using Boundary Object Theory[J]. Government Information Quarterly, 2017, 34(3), pp.406-420.
[32] Kokko J., Vartiainen T., & Tuunanen T. Value Co-creation and Co-destruction in Online Video Games : An Exploratory Study and Implications for Future Research[C]. Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences, 2018, 1158-1167.
[33] Jmour A. and Hmida I. C. B. Not always Co-creation: Exploratory Study of Reasons, Emotions and Practices of the Value Co-destruction in Virtual Communities[C]. International Conference on Digital Economy, 2017, 41-54.
[34] McColl-Kennedy J. R., Vargo S. L., Dagger T. S., Sweeney J. C., and Van Kasteren Y. Health Care Customer Value Cocreation Practice Styles[J]. Journal of Service Research, 2012,15(4), pp.370-389.
[35] Cˇaic＇ M., Odekerken-Schroder G., Mahr D. Service Robots: Value Co-creation and Co-destruction in Elderly Care Networks[J]. Journal of Service Management, 2018,29(2), pp.1-47.
[36] Voorhees C. M., Brady M. K., and Horowitz D. M. A Voice from the Silent Masses: An Exploratory and Comparative Analysis of Noncomplainers[J]. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 2006, 34 (4), pp. 514-27.
[37] Yousefian J. Value Co-creation and Value Co-destruction in the Sport Service Sector: Is Customer Engagement always Beneficial[C]. Conference of the European Association for Sport Management, 2013.
[38] 张辉, 汪涛, 刘洪深. 新产品开发中的顾客参与研究综述[J]. 中国科技论坛, 2010,(11):105-111.
[39] 姚山季, 王永贵, 来尧静.顾客参与新产品开发及其结果影响的综述[J]. 科技管理研究, 2011,(7):221-224.
[40] Gyrd-Jones R. I., and Kornum N. Managing the Co-created Brand: Value and Cultural Complementary in Online and Offline Multi-Stakeholder Ecosystems[J]. Journal of Business Research,2013, 66(9), pp.1484-1493.
[41] Pee L. G. Learning through Ill-Structured Problems: A Technology-enabled Co-creation Approach[C]. IEEE International Conference on Information Society, 2016.
[42] 李朝辉, 金永生, 卜庆娟. 顾客参与虚拟品牌社区价值共创对品牌资产影响研究——品牌体验的中介作用[J]. 营销科学学报, 2014, 10(4):109-124.
[43] 李朝辉.虚拟品牌社区环境下顾客参与价值共创对品牌体验的影响[J]. 财经论丛,2014,183(7):75-81.
[44] Hoyer W. D., Chandy R., Dorotic M., Krafft M., and Singh S. S. Customer Cocreation in New Product Development[J]. Journal of Service Research, 2010,13(3), pp.283-296.